Companies of Heroes M226 Pershing Quote Dispute

The debate surrounding the classification of the M226 Pershing tank has been ongoing for some time, with conflicting opinions on its designation as either a heavy or medium tank. This article aims to shed light on the matter by examining the sources and arguments presented.

According to Striker5810, the controversy began when the game Companies of Heroes included the M226 Pershing as a heavy tank, despite it not being recognized as such in real-life history books. It is claimed that this decision was influenced by the modeling and tabletop community, which often blurs the lines between game design and reality.

The sources cited by proponents of the M226's classification as a heavy tank are often poorly made Wikipedia-esque pages that contain multiple factual errors. Striker5810 argues that these sources do not accurately represent historical facts, instead relying on hearsay and unsubstantiated claims.

A closer examination of the sources reveals that they claim the M226 was redesignated from a medium tank to a heavy tank, only to be later reclassified back to its original designation as a medium tank. This argument is based on incomplete information and lacks concrete evidence.

In contrast, Teen Male Usagi points out that every source presented by proponents of the M226's classification as a heavy tank confirms that it is, in fact, a medium tank.

The lack of credible sources supporting the M226's designation as a heavy tank raises questions about the accuracy of these claims. The redesignation theory, which relies on incomplete information and unsubstantiated claims, does not hold up to scrutiny.

In conclusion, while there may be ongoing debates among historians and enthusiasts, the majority of reliable sources confirm that the M226 Pershing is a medium tank, rather than a heavy one. It is essential to prioritize accuracy and credible evidence when discussing historical facts, rather than relying on incomplete or inaccurate information.

Companies of heroes m226 pershing quote